The Home Valuation Code of Conduct (HVCC) was implemented on May 1st and requires new methods for conducting home appraisals. This three month old code is clearly creating challenges for Denver home sellers, buyers, and parties involved in the real estate transaction.
At present, HVCC affects real estate deals (purchase and refinance on 1-4 single family loans) that involve a conventional Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan product. Federal Home Bank Loans, FHA, and VA loans are currently exempt from the code.
Home Valuation Code of Conduct was designed to prevent practices of collusion between unscrupulous lenders and appraisers who were attempting to artificially inflate property values.
Instigated as a result of a lawsuit:
New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo sued an appraisal subsidiary division of First American Corp for allegedly colluding with Washington Mutual to push home values. http://www.reuters.com/article/bondsNews/idUSN0143151620071101
In short, and in an effort to ensure an independent appraisal by a non-vested third party with no financial stakes to the transaction, limits were placed on the lender/appraisal relationship.
As a result, appraisal management companies (AMC) were introduced to create a “level playing field”. This is generating additional barriers and time delays on the under-contract to close process for home sellers and home buyers.
While commendable on paper, in real estate practice this is biggest obstacle facing home sellers:
Appraisers who are chosen randomly through the appraisal management company may be called in from outside their geographic territories. Unfortunately, these appraisers are sent to neighborhoods in which they are completely unfamiliar. While this might sound insignificant it is clearly negatively affecting home values.
Even in a fairly homogenized community like Highlands Ranch a simple street boundary can make a considerable difference when considering comparable homes.
I live in a sub-area of only 300 homes yet there are three subtle pockets of this neighborhood that impact price in as much as $100,000 or more. An appraiser from Loveland coming to Highlands Ranch is unlikely to appreciate these pricing nuances.
The fall-out in this new process is that homes are coming in well under appraisal.
Proactive measures for sellers who are concerned about appraisal:
There is a misconception that real estate agents are not allowed to meet the appraiser. We can. While there are no guarantees in this new appraisal frontier – make sure your listing agent attends the appraisal and is armed with the following:
1). A list of comparable homes recently sold in your actual neighborhood taken from the local Metrolist (MLS) service.
2). A list of all improvements, upgrades, location differences or anything else that supports the purchase price.
3). All available interior, exterior or virtual tours of recently sold homes.
Clear communication between the listing agent and the appraiser along with thorough supporting data can certainly reduce the chances of a surprisingly ugly appraisal.
Read more on the how the HVCC is impacting Denver home sellers and buyers at: http://www.realtor.org/research/economists_outlook/commentaries/appraisals0709
Michelle A. Potter
Denver Realtor
Re/Max Professionals















